More General posts
June 04, 2002
Cross blog commenting

Juri Pakaste has an interesting post on his blog about Comments on blogs. I have conflicting feelings about this issue. On the one hand I want content on my blog, its hard enought to write stuff as it is without scattering it across the web :) On the other, comments are a nice form of conversation that I would like to encourage, and being able to read many peoples different (possibly) views on a subject on one site is useful.

The one possibly novel feature I want to try to implement in my toy blog project is cross blog commenting. The idea is that if two people are using this software to run their blogs then it is possible for one of them to comment on a post on the other's blog and and have that appear as a post on their own blog. With appropriate crosslinking I could post a comment on Juri's site which would appear as a post on mine with a link to the head of the discussion on his. With multiple participating sites I could imagine quite a rich system where you could click across multiple blogs reading a thread of comments with the benefit of seeing other articles on the blogs as well, browsing being part of the benefit of blogs. In some fantasy land view perhaps the sum of the parts could be greater than the whole and you'd end up with a sort of hyper blog made up of connected crosslinking blogs.

Posted by Alex at June 04, 2002 08:09 PM
Comments
You can Google for BlogML; results two and three are especially interesting. That might be a good starting point. It would be really nice to see all the content interspersed together in a coherent argument. What would be really nifty would be to have threading work automagically somehow. Posted by: Nathan on June 4, 2002 10:29 PM
Looks interesting. This sort of thing would be necessary. As for getting all the content together in one place I think that could be done. I can think of various possibilities but I'm always worried that I'll end up with an over engineered solution. For instance it would be possible to use the XML-RPC calls from the blogger api (perhaps with some extensions) to trace the cross posting thread across various blogs. Each participating blog could then present a view of the thread with such content as it wanted to show. Need to have some way to prevent this being used as a denial of service attack but something could probably be worked out. Posted by: on June 5, 2002 07:40 PM
Over engineer a solution? You? I'm glad I know that you also have a pragmatic side that prevents you from just jumping into the deep end of the code pool. Posted by: mss on June 5, 2002 08:13 PM
Post a comment
Name:


Email Address:


URL:


Comments:


Remember info?